How Policy May Redirect Innovation

June 8, 2021

#
IMAGE: LOREM IPSUM
Find out how government policies can encourage or slow down innovation and creative activities.

June 2021 ・ 4 minutes reading time

Government policies can affect the rate and, to some extent, the direction of innovative activities. Some of these policies, such as R&D tax incentives, protection of intellectual property (IP) rights, encourage innovation.

There are also policies and regulations – intended to target legitimate social objectives separate from innovative-related ones – that may have an unintended effect on innovative activities. A few of them can slow down the rate or shift the creative activities elsewhere.

Estimated reading time: 4 minutes
(Sanjeri / E+)

When policies have unintended consequences

In the early 1990s, a handful of European countries were at the forefront of transgenic crop innovation. As transgenic crops started being produced and sold commercially, a separate but related push against transgenic crops from European consumer groups took the stage. This group was concerned with the potential adverse effects of transgenically produced crops. Europe's precautionary principle then took effect, which altered the European innovation landscape in this technological field.

In the mid-1990s, the European Union (EU) implemented a de facto moratorium on plants produced by genetic modification. The measure established specific requirements for how field tests for new transgenic crops were conducted and planted, imported and used, labeled, and eventually sold for consumption. This rule, intended to safeguard consumer welfare, appears to have slowed down patent filings in the region ever since.

A relatively recent EU decision ruled on transgenic crops' equivalence produced using the CRIPSR-Cas9 technique with conventional GMOs. This decision may have had a further chilling effect on agricultural biotechnology's research and development on the continent.

Total patent filings of plant biotechnology, 1970-2016

Slowdown in the patent filing activities from European crop
(source: WIPO, based on WIPR 2019 data)

This figure shows the share of agricultural biotechnology patenting over total patent filings for the U.S. and several European countries. From the 1980s, the share of patents filed in the industry has been increasing faster than the average filings for both the U.S. and EU-28 countries. However, from 1995 onward, there is a widening gap between the patent filing growth rates in the U.S. and EU-28. It is difficult to say conclusively if this is due to Europe's de facto moratorium without further research. But since 1998, the EU-28 countries have been filing at a relatively slower rate than the total patent filing rate in this technology field.

What does this mean for further innovation?

The way in which policies intended to address specific social concerns may affect innovation is challenging to determine at the onset. This is not to say that governments should not enact policies to safeguard its citizen. Rather, governments should be aware of the potential effects their policies may have on innovative activities in their countries and mitigate potential adverse impacts accordingly.

Related resources

The Geography of Innovation

The World Intellectual Property Report 2019 documents how the geography of innovation has evolved over the past few decades.

The Global Network of Local Innovation

In this paper we exploit a unique and rich dataset of patent applications and scientific publications...

Disclaimer: The short posts and articles included in the Innovation Economics Themes Series typically report on research in progress and are circulated in a timely manner for discussion and comment. The views expressed in them are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of WIPO or its Member States. ​​​​​​​

Related stories

The World of Innovation Capabilities

Mapping the world’s knowledge can empower innovation policy makers to make informed decisions.

How Can Scrabble Guide Policymaking?

The game of Scrabble can shed light on why some countries and regions grow faster than others. It also offers valuable lessons for those striving to catch up. Read more to find out how!

Austria’s Efforts to Empower Women in Innovation and Patenting

Engaging women in science, technology and innovation is crucial for societies to address pressing social and economic issues. Drawing from Austria’s recent ranking in female inventor rates across Europe, the Austrian Patent Office conducted a qualitative study to identify and ramp up pivotal initiatives for empowering women in innovation and patenting. Let’s take a look at these initiatives!

More than Just Fun: TM Filings Suggest Video Game Makers Are Investing in Well-being and Education

Many view video games as merely a leisure activity. But data from WIPO’s Global Brands Database suggest that the video game makers are increasingly investing in well-being and education. Learn more about this.