About Intellectual Property IP Training Respect for IP IP Outreach IP for… IP and... IP in... Patent & Technology Information Trademark Information Industrial Design Information Geographical Indication Information Plant Variety Information (UPOV) IP Laws, Treaties & Judgements IP Resources IP Reports Patent Protection Trademark Protection Industrial Design Protection Geographical Indication Protection Plant Variety Protection (UPOV) IP Dispute Resolution IP Office Business Solutions Paying for IP Services Negotiation & Decision-Making Development Cooperation Innovation Support Public-Private Partnerships AI Tools & Services The Organization Working with WIPO Accountability Patents Trademarks Industrial Designs Geographical Indications Copyright Trade Secrets WIPO Academy Workshops & Seminars IP Enforcement WIPO ALERT Raising Awareness World IP Day WIPO Magazine Case Studies & Success Stories IP News WIPO Awards Business Universities Indigenous Peoples Judiciaries Genetic Resources, Traditional Knowledge and Traditional Cultural Expressions Economics Finance Intangible Assets Gender Equality Global Health Climate Change Competition Policy Sustainable Development Goals Frontier Technologies Mobile Applications Sports Tourism PATENTSCOPE Patent Analytics International Patent Classification ARDI – Research for Innovation ASPI – Specialized Patent Information Global Brand Database Madrid Monitor Article 6ter Express Database Nice Classification Vienna Classification Global Design Database International Designs Bulletin Hague Express Database Locarno Classification Lisbon Express Database Global Brand Database for GIs PLUTO Plant Variety Database GENIE Database WIPO-Administered Treaties WIPO Lex - IP Laws, Treaties & Judgments WIPO Standards IP Statistics WIPO Pearl (Terminology) WIPO Publications Country IP Profiles WIPO Knowledge Center WIPO Technology Trends Global Innovation Index World Intellectual Property Report PCT – The International Patent System ePCT Budapest – The International Microorganism Deposit System Madrid – The International Trademark System eMadrid Article 6ter (armorial bearings, flags, state emblems) Hague – The International Design System eHague Lisbon – The International System of Appellations of Origin and Geographical Indications eLisbon UPOV PRISMA UPOV e-PVP Administration UPOV e-PVP DUS Exchange Mediation Arbitration Expert Determination Domain Name Disputes Centralized Access to Search and Examination (CASE) Digital Access Service (DAS) WIPO Pay Current Account at WIPO WIPO Assemblies Standing Committees Calendar of Meetings WIPO Webcast WIPO Official Documents Development Agenda Technical Assistance IP Training Institutions COVID-19 Support National IP Strategies Policy & Legislative Advice Cooperation Hub Technology and Innovation Support Centers (TISC) Technology Transfer Inventor Assistance Program WIPO GREEN WIPO's Pat-INFORMED Accessible Books Consortium WIPO for Creators WIPO Translate Speech-to-Text Classification Assistant Member States Observers Director General Activities by Unit External Offices Job Vacancies Procurement Results & Budget Financial Reporting Oversight
Arabic English Spanish French Russian Chinese
Laws Treaties Judgments Browse By Jurisdiction

Jordan

JO002-j

Back

Court of Appeal of Amman, Jordan [2009]: Case No. 40706/2009

This is an informal case summary prepared for the purposes of facilitating exchange during the 2024 WIPO IP Judges Forum.

 

 

Session 5

 

Court of Appeal of Amman, Jordan [2009]: Case No. 40706/2009

 

Date of judgment: August 30, 2019

Issuing authority: Amman Court of Appeal

Level of the issuing authority: Appellate Instance

Type of procedure: Judicial (Criminal)

Subject matter: Copyright and Related Rights (Neighboring Rights)

Plaintiff: Ministry of Education

Defendant: A group of teachers

Keywords: copyright exceptions; credit to the original author

 

Basic facts: The Ministry of Education (Plaintiff) filed a complaint against a group of math teachers in private schools (the Defendants), alleging copyright infringement. The teachers were accused of issuing a mathematics booklet that essentially replicated the content of the teacher's guide produced by the Ministry. The Defendants denied the allegations, claiming that their actions merely involved preparing and compiling educational materials to teach their students.

In the first instance, the court found copyright infringement and ruled in favor of the plaintiff. The Defendants appealed the decision.

 

Held:  The Court of Appeal upheld the lower court's decision, dismissing the appeal and affirming the copyright infringement. Each defendant was fined one thousand dinars, and all booklet copies were ordered to be confiscated.

 

Relevant holdings in relation to Copyright: The Court of Appeal dismissed the Defendants' argument that their actions fell within the exceptions provided under Article 17 of the Copyright Law. This law allows the use of published works without the author's permission under specific conditions, such as for educational purposes, provided there is no financial gain and the author is credited.

 

The Court of Appeal noted that the Defendants' actions did not meet these criteria, as they produced a new work under their names without properly crediting the original author. The Court of Appeal emphasized that simply referring to the original work in the introduction was insufficient; proper citation and acknowledgment were required. Furthermore, the Court of Appeal found that Article 20 of the Copyright Law, which pertains to copying, also did not apply, as the Defendants had failed to credit the original author in their replicated work. Consequently, the Court of Appeal concluded that the Defendants' actions constituted copyright infringement.

 

Additionally, the Court of Appeal rejected the Defendants' claim that the teacher's guide did not qualify as a protected work under the Copyright Law, affirming that it was indeed covered by Article 3.

                                                                                      

Relevant legislation:

·         Criminal Procedure Law of 1961

·         Copyright and Neighboring Rights Law of 1992

·         Civil Code of 1976